The New York Metropolitans landed the best starting pitcher alive in the most-anticipated and -publicized trade since the Yankees traded for Alex Rodriguez before the 2004 season. It’s a damn shame for the fans of Minnesota, who, when the Twins needed a new ballpark, said they will pay the tax to help build it. Now the Twins have repaid their fans by dealing off Johan Santana. It should be noted that Santana turned down a four year, $80 million offer, but it should also be noted that the Twins signed first baseman Justin Morneau to a six-year extension and outfielder Michael Cuddyer to a three-year extension. Remember also, Twins owner Carl Pohlad is one of the richest men in America.
The real problem though is that, with the Yankees and Red Sox standing pat, the Twins got no prospects in return that will become stars. The Mets held onto super prospect Fernando Martinez. They also kept Mike Pelfrey, who has had limited and unsuccessful MLB experience, but has the tools to be a front-of-the-rotation starter.
Since the Twins couldn’t get the Mets’ top prospect from a year ago (Pelfrey) or their current top prospect (Martinez), they had to look elsewhere. Philip Humber was once a can’t-miss prospect drafted third overall in 2004. A subpar season and Tommy John surgery later, the now 25-year-old has made only one Major League start. He could very well win a spot the Twins rotation in spring training, but profiles as a back-of-the-rotation guy. Deolis Guerra could be a wild card in this trade, simply because of his youth. The right-handed starting pitcher projects–like the others–as an average, back-end starter. However, since his 19th birthday is in April, no one truly knows how he may develop. Kevin Mulvey, the third right-handed starter in the group, went 11-10 in AA last year and won his only appearance at the AAA level. He, like Humber, is close to the Majors, but also like Humber, seems to be a fourth or fifth starter. The only position player traded in the Santana deal was Carlos Gomez. He is an interesting player and has the inside track on the centerfield job for the Twins in 2008. Not many are in Torii Hunter’s class defensively, but Gomez has the speed to cover a lot of ground. In fact, he will be one of the fastest players in MLB should he make the Twins’ big league club. In just 141 plate appearances with the Mets last year, he stole 12 bases. However, his ability to get on base will determine whether he leads off or hits 9th.
The Twins will be just fine because their scouting and development of prospects has been so top notch under the reign of former General Manager (now a top consulant) Terry Ryan. Glen Perkins, Kevin Slowey, Francisco Liriano, Nick Blackburn, Scott Baker, and Boof Bonser are all talented and young starting pitchers. The Twins have a formidable lineup with Joe Mauer, Justin Morneau, and Michael Cuddyer hitting third, fourth, and fifth. However, without Fernando Martinez or Mike Pelfrey in the deal, the Twins simply did not get enough for Johan Santana. To give up a megastar like Santana–the new best left-handed starting pitcher of his generation–they needed a cornerstone type of player in return, and no one of this foursome from the Mets is that.