Andre Ethier had a solid 2007 for the Dodgers, (his OPS just breaking the .800 mark) a season after finishing 5th in the NL Rookie of the Year voting. The Dodgers acquired Ethier, who had just been named the Texas League MVP, in 2005 from the Oakland Athletics for ticking time bomb Milton Bradley. But this story is not about Ethier’s gain so much as it is about who is not starting.
That would be Juan Pierre. The same Juan Pierre who made $7,500,000 for the Dodgers in 2007 in the first year of 5-year, $45 million contract signed the offseason before. What’s not to like about Pierre? A Spanish first name. A French last name. Yet he is a black American from the South. He looks like a kid and plays the game with the same passion. He would fit in perfectly on the teams between The Wars with his baggy uniform and floppy cap as well as his stolen bases and bunts for hits.
He just isn’t a $9 million per season player.
Any sabermatician will point out that Pierre finished in the top 3 in the NL in outs made for five straight seasons. Well, part of that is because he is a leadoff hitter who gets more at bats than the others, but the reality is that he is a leadoff hitter who got on base just 33% of the time last season and his slugging percentage looks an awful lot like his batting average.
Many thought that Pierre would be the starter to showcase him for a possible trade. Or at least to avoid the embarassment of having a $9 million per season benchwarmer.
Ethier made $387,500 in 2007 and will make a similar figure this season.
So what did the Dodgers do this offseason? They signed a power hitter who slugged .413 last season and struck out 138 times. Oh, and Andruw Jones has lost a step defensively, too. His is only a two-year contract, but worth $36 million.
Including budding star Matt Kemp, that leaves the Dodgers with four outfielders who should be starters at the Major League level.
It is becoming a developing trend throughout MLB to let youngsters (and their pre-arbitration eligible salaries) play over over-priced veterans, but the Los Angeles Dodgers’ best offseason acquisition leading into the 2008 season may very well be Joe Torre. Torre’s most important attribute as manager has always been his ability to manage the egos that get in the way of winning baseball games. Ask Yankee fans. Torre never hesitated to drop Paul O’Neill in the lineup. Or sit Bernie Williams. Or jerk Roger Clemens in a playoff game before he was eligible for the win. Or pull Mike Mussina from the rotation. The Dodgers and Joe Torre will put a millionaire on the bench in favor of a 26-year old, but the Los Angeles Dodgers will be a better and deeper team for it.
UPDATE: Juan Pierre did not play in the Dodgers’ opener, ending his consecutive games played streak at 434 games.