Cole Hamels is one of the best starting pitchers in the game. He ranks second in the Majors in strikeouts (133), innings pitched (150.7), and fourth in WHIP (1.01). While Hamels should finish in the top-5 of the National League Cy Young Award vote, the other starters in Philadelphia’s rotation have not been good.
Brett Myers, the Phillies’ Opening Day starter, has an ERA of 5.84 and had to be sent down to Triple-A. Adam Eaton hasn’t been much better. With the addition of Blanton, the Phillies are sending Eaton and his 5.71 ERA to the bullpen. Second-year righty Kyle Kendrick is 8-4, but his ERA isn’t good either at 4.87.
45-year-old Jamie Moyer has been a solid sidekick to Hamels as he continues to get people out on very limited stuff. He is 9-6 with a 3.90 ERA for the 2008 season.
Joe Blanton isn’t flashy. He is a solid right-hander who throws just above 90 mph with an average breaking ball. However, if Kyle Kendrick has won twice as many games as he’s lost in 2008, Blanton could be a great addition. Blanton’s dependability could translate into several wins behind Philadelphia’s prolific offense. He’s made at least 31 starts and logged at least 194 innings in each of his three Major League seasons.
Blanton is one of the original Moneyballers, drafted in the first round of out of the University of Kentucky in 2002. He finished 6th in the 2004 AL Rookie of the Year vote by posting a 12-12 mark with a 3.53 ERA. He won a career-high 16 games in 2005, though his ERA ballooned to 4.82. Last season, Blanton took over duties as staff ace and logged a whopping 230 innings, but kept his ERA (3.95) under 4.00. His career ERA is 4.25, just above the league average of 4.24.
Joe Blanton is not yet arbitration eligible and made only $380,000 in 2007. The Phillies will take no risk monetarily, and Blanton isn’t scheduled to become a free agent until after the 2010 season. However, while Blanton’s durability almost guarantees that he is able to throw 200 inning annually, his rough 2008 season is concerning. He is 27 years old and, although his MLB career is relatively short, his best years could already be behind him. Plus, Oakland general manager Billy Beane seems to have a knack for trading away pitchers just as they begin the downside of their careers. (See: Barry Zito and Mark Mulder.)
Billy Beane is running laps around the rest of the general managers in Major League Baseball. This trade is no blockbuster, but supply and demand ensured that Beane maximized Blanton’s value. Adrian Cardenas was named the High School Player of the Year by Baseball America his senior season at a Miami, Florida high school and was the Phillies’ best position prospect. Cardenas is a second baseman–obviously blocked at that position in Philadelphia by superstar Chase Utley–that will more than likely be a top-30 overall prospect going into 2009. Since the Athletics drafted University of Miami second baseman Jemile Weeks last month in the first round, Cardenas may very well end up playing third base in the Major Leagues, but scouts believe his bat will be powerful enough to play at the hot corner. The Athletics also received Josh Outman, a left-hander who ranked as the Phillies’ fourth-best prospect entering 2008. He has moved to the bullpen and has a 3.20 ERA in Double-A. Matt Spencer is a second-year outfielder who is struggling at Class High-A.
Cardenas is a prized hitting prospect, but Billy Beane was able to pry him away from the Phillies even though Joe Blanton is having the worst season of his MLB career. Blanton is just 5-12 with 4.96 ERA in 2008. While the National League will not be as strong as Blanton’s American League foes, Philadelphia’s park is grossly different than Oakland’s pitcher-friendly park. Despite the poor numbers, Blanton was one of the best pitchers available in the trade market. Beyond the supply and demand factor, the New York Mets have been on fire of late and are tied for the NL East lead, heightening Philadelphia’s urgency to acquire a starting pitcher. Now Blanton is thrust in the midst of an exciting playoff race. He will make his Philadelphia Phillies debut tomorrow in Shea Stadium versus Johan Santana and the New York Mets.